I see some positive signs that our market may be stabilizing or "bottoming out".
There are certainly still depressing stats out there like:
But – here are some positives:
Don’t forget – closing costs. These costs are substantial in SW FL. A portion of these costs that are negotiable in the contract for sale/purchase. On average any buyer can use 1.5% of the purchase price as a standard rule of thumb for these costs. That is a lot of money. We need to always discuss this. http://www.swfhomesales.com/ClosingCosts
Don’t forget: Buyers tend to refuse to buy when property is dropping in price. Buyers want to buy when prices are increasing. The time to buy is on the down side. People are inherently afraid they will “miss the bottom”. You will irregardless of what action you take. In real estate, any time you think you see the bottom – you have already missed it. In a market like this one, buying at this stage of the market, you will be fine at any time in the next 2-5 years.
As I try to evaluate......The recent reports - numbers - hype.......
inaccuracies need to have a few clarifications:
Wall(nut) St. thought the 16% jump in new home sales reported for April was a good thing. Really? How do think that happened and at what cost? At least here it happened with:
The SW FL market has done the same things only worse.
The other side of the coin
IF you don't absolutely have to sell right now - don't
IF you can wait until a year from now to sell - do
IF you must sell now - price the property in the lower 10% of comparable properties - offer incentives - make it stand out from the crowd.... take the hit.
IF you can buy now - do
The coming storm season will likely have a lot to do with how the market reacts and what the market is like six months from now.
Summary:
Thanks for your time - this time - til next time....
As we look toward the buyer side of this market and as I continue to pound away at the opportunities for buyers here.... there are a number of incredible incentives being offered by builders/developers for the summer months. I should talk about them as well as all the "down side" seller - processes. Contact me to discuss details of these incentive programs currently available or;
See sample details of these incentives on my web site
Either way - there are numerous and varied programs in the market place today.
When you read the news - just today - you find items like:
This type of info. makes it difficult to put a positive spin on things (except the Lennar pricing - if you are a buyer in this market). I have been putting an honest "spin" on it for the past year. Check my notes from yesterday that basically said - "the next 3 months are the best time to be a buyer in this market". This is the toughest time for seller pricing. And, it will be improving by Thanksgiving. I am not saying price increases but activity levels will increase due to passing the bottom of this market cycle.
Back to the issue. Currently, it is very difficult to be involved in the real estate business in this area. It wasn't too difficult for the realtor and the seller that had a listing go pending for $6.2M - just yesterday. But for the other 9,000 realtors and 27,000 sellers in SW FL, it was another difficult day.
Buyers days are great right now - contact me today
Here is the quote from the national press release dated 5/24/07,
“Sales of new homes surged in April by the biggest amount (16%) in 14 years, but the median price of a new home dropped (11%) by the largest amount on record. The mixed signals left no clear picture of whether the worst of the housing slump is over or not.”
The SW FL market did not have that much of an increase in April although - as discussed here previously - we did have an end of season "surge".
Here are the results for the first 24 days of May and comparing them to the entire month for prior years:
Bonita-Estero
May ‘07
May ‘06
May ‘05
May ‘04
Pending
111
123
254
243
Sold
112
144
309
244
Estero – only
30
39
71
37
31
Naples (W. of I-75)
Naples
283
346
773
783
281
376
776
790
The month of May appears to be on target to “track” with the May ’06 results. That would indicate – to me –
What does this tell us? What I have been saying for a while – it appears we are at the bottom of this cycle. This summer is the time to take advantage of this market. If you are buyer – you will not buy at a better time than NOW. There is no better time to be a buyer than NOW.
Contact me to discuss this today.
This story just reminds us that CBS and 60 minutes segments have zero credibility with regard to accurate - fair - journalistic - truth. The next time you are watching any segment of theirs - remember how they distort the truth and categorically refuse to report in any semblance of "fair".
Here are some truths about realtors:
It is unbelievable that 60 minutes would take - this approach - in this market - at this time. Am I making a zillion $ like they say?
Let me give you some insight into a transaction that I just completed. 1st of all, I was the listing agent.
I just gave up on two listings that I have been marketing for 6 months. I have spent thousands of dollars on marketing these properties and they won't sell. I am not sure as to the why but I know I can't sell them. I have invested six months, a lot of sweat and lot of money in these. I must walk away with nothing. I feel terrible for the seller too. I have done everything I know how to do and the seller has done most of the things necessary to market the properties. That includes reducing the prices to a level where the seller would be in a loss position if they were to sell. Yeah, this is a get rich quick scheme, isn't it?
One more topic needs to be addressed. That is the part about the discount real estate broker and or the internet discount broker. The bottom line to that is best explained by real life examples. I recently had a transaction with one of these "discounters".
Surely this will provoke some comments.....
The Bella Terra residential community east on Corkscrew Road in Estero wants to offer affordable apartments for people who work in the immediate area. These would be built at the end of the proposed shopping center area on the SW corner of Corkscrew Rd. and Bella Terra Blvd. (just before the entrance on Corkscrew).The developers plan to build -
Too expensive for the location and value? Yeah, it all is. Here is something for you to ponder - Their proposal is 875 sq. ft., 2 bdr. for $840. / mo. My younger daughter lives in St. Louis, Mo. (just E. of Forest Park) - she has a 1 bdr., 700 sq. ft. apartment and pays just almost exactly that amount.
Now what do you think about this proposal?
The MLS numbers shown below represent "pending" and "closed" transactions for the month of May then compare them to the complete month of May for the prior 3 years.
Bonita Springs - Estero
Pending - May Sold - May Sold - May (Estero only)
'07 - 75 '07 - 59 (16)
'06 – 123 '06 – 144 (39)
'05 – 254 '05 – 309 (71)
'04 – 243 '04 – 204 (37)
The first half of the month is most curious. The pending numbers are beating a year ago. In an earlier blog, I commented that April pending beat '06 by so much that May sold or closed sales would look very positive compared to the prior year. Where are they? The April pending numbers far exceeded '06 (which become May closed). Now May pending appears to be ahead of '06, by a large percentage. If the current results were to carry 2 more weeks, we would have a May pending increase of about 25% over one year ago. Let's see if the closings catch up the last two weeks (to where they should be). If that happens, we have the 1st positive news in this market in the last two years. Will we see that? Are we around a turn here? Stay tuned.......
Naples W. of I-75
'07 - 185 '07 - 186
'06 - 346 '06 - 376
'05 - 773 '05 - 776
'04 - 783 '04 - 790
At this pace, Naples will beat May '06. If the next 2 weeks are equal to the 1st two weeks, the pending market would be ahead of '06 by 10%. That bodes well for the summer months as it will obviously continue the closings for June to finish ahead of the prior years. If this holds, it would be the most positive market indicator in the past 2 years. Again, like the Bonita-Estero market info. above, the closings must catch up in the last two weeks of the month. Time will tell.........
Will this hold? Is it the indicator it appears to be? What about the other negatives?
Your thoughts?
With all the focus on Coconut Point mall and up the road at Gulf Coast Town Center, smaller development projects are making progress in Estero too. The growth in this small area is phenomenal. Understand that Coconut Pt. has 1.4 M sq. ft. under air and more to be built while Gulf Coast is excess 800k built and still building and Miromar Outlets is just finishing phase 5, moving it to 140 stores! Below is a summary of current additional commercial growth on highway 41, Corkscrew Rd., Three Oaks, etc.
What do you think? Is Estero truly the center of growth in SW Florida?
What is the single biggest waste of money in marketing a home/property?
That's simple.... print advertising - most specifically - newspaper....
That cost is almost always borne by the agent - from their potential money. I know the property owner wants the ads and wants to see the ads but honestly, it is a major waste of money. Just as a thought...... In almost all cases, the actual agent pays 100% of that cost - not the agency/broker. With that now out for air - I know more and more listing agents that refuse to do newspaper advertising and stipulate as much in their listing presentation.
I feel the same way. A 1/8 page ad in either local paper will cost about $500. per day. How many days do you want to run that ad - in this market? There are many many more cost effective ways to spend that money.
Give me your thoughts on best marketing techniques.
This is your market conditions update for the 1st 10 days of May. How is it doing now that season is over? How are we doing as the market makes that change?
It does actually look like the market may be stabilizing...... For ex:
These numbers for '07 are for the 1st 10 days as prior years are for the complete month
Pending - May Sold - May (Estero)
'07 - 60 '07 - 48 (12)
'07 - 150 '07 - 150
This pace for the entire month would "blow away" '06 and indicate that we have bottomed out and are seeing increasing transactions activity. Is it right? Depends on the next 3 weeks of results...... Stay tuned.....
What are you doing about your property insurance? Please post your thoughts and comments.....This is one of the 3 items killing the local real estate market.
I am absolutely incensed and am working diligently toward a substantial improvement. Notice, I said improvement. I can't cure this alone.
I am going to develop an independent insurance agency that has access to:
I am working on finalizing all the company appointments for this. Due to prior relationships and prior experience, I can establish an agency - here - that will, in fact, be able to do the things I have listed above.
Do you think it can be established in this area and be worthwhile?
The data included here is at least interesting if not close to amazing and contradictory to all that supposedly know (including yours truly). This would indicate that we are off the bottom of this market. This activity level is actually surprising (even to me). Now, the overriding questions are:
Remember, this data is from the combined MLS. This data does not include
This is pretty amazing data. How long has it been since we have had 1,670 pending properties in Lee County?
Don't get me wrong. This is one - and only one - indicator for this market. It is the most positive one I have seen in two years. The negative indicator also shown in these stats is that active listings continues to hover around the 25k mark. This have built up over the past two years and is now staying there. Obviously, this number must reduce significantly for recovery to occur.
My personal opinion: it will be rough and rocky travelin' from Cinco de Mayo (see photo at right) to Thanksgiving. Stay tuned..... what do you think?
The number one item on the agenda of the FL Legislature was the state property tax issue and they choked again. Typically, politically, they choked. The legislature will have a special session in mid-June to address this hot issue. The Governor made a statement that he certainly believed we could see real relief come to fruition yet this year. Don't hold your breath.
Yes, it is tough. A very daunting task of righting the ship of this state was ahead of this legislature and this session. They have deferred their real task for a few months while their aides try to find politically correct ways to make the voters believe they are standing up to the task. What we have is
One of the other two issues is property insurance. The legislature did take a couple of positive steps by freezing citizen (the state run insurer) rates again and "tweaking" the rate filing process for insurance companies. These changes will make rate increases a little more difficult. That doesn't exactly save the day. What we must have is some insurers that are willing to do the ratin gcorrectly and stop gouging the public just because they can. Stay tuned on this topic....
What do you think?
This is a statistical look at the "state of the business" on 5/1/07. These stats are telling us where we stand as we begin the "off season".
MLS records: Active residential property listings by city:
Number of new listings added in April compared to the 3 yr. avg.
Bonita Springs - Estero combined: 488 3 yr. avg.: 433
Naples: 1,476 3 yr. avg.: 1,459
This doesn't indicate any real appreciable reduction in listings being added to the mls. Media reports recently indicate different information. For example, reports concerning number of residents occupying or moving into properties indicate a large inventory reduction. That report did not account for the number of those "move ins" as tenants. It is a very large percentage. The number of transactions are not enough to exceed the number of new listings added. That is the only way to reduce inventory and that is the only way to find the bottom of the market.......
That's at least interesting. According to the news releases, there is renewed interest in their attempt to find solutions to property tax woes.
Let's think about it. The following are "their" numbers:
This is something of a "drop in the bucket" but a large "drop". What is your opinion? Let me know
Let's evaluate the sales results (as recorded on the mls) for Bonita Springs and Estero.
194
169
141
289
56
46
77
45
135
134
149
315
282
33
29
32
79
49
$547k
$570k
$520k
What does this tell us? This is a good barometer month to use as April is historically the busiest "transactions" month in this market.
Does this mean the summer months will be more active than anticipated?
Does this mean the bottom has been reached?
Or will the summer months bring activity doldrums and further price retreats?
What are your opinions and what other comparisons would you like to see?